Each new detail we learn about JoJo Siwa and Kylie Prew’s relationship is even cuter than the last. During an appearance on the Success With Jess podcast on Aug. 21, the couple sat down to talk about everything from when they started dating to how they told each other “I love you.” The 18-year-old Dance Moms alum also dished on how they both asked each other to be their girlfriend, and let’s just say, JoJo went big. “I had a whole musical number,” JoJo shared. “I had like word choreography that coordinated to music, and then it went into a song after the word [choreography]. It was magical.”

The adorable duo first went public with their romance in February, shortly after JoJo came out as a part of the LGBTQ+ community on Instagram. During an appearance on The Tonight Show, JoJo shared that Kylie was “super encouraging” about her decision to come out, calling her “the most amazing, wonderful, perfect, most beautiful girlfriend in the whole world.” Learn more about their sweet relationship as you watch the video above.