Categories
Politics

Liz Cheney’s Unlikely Journey From G.O.P. Royalty to Republican Outcast

CASPER, Wyo. — Representative Liz Cheney was holed up in a secure undisclosed location of the Dick Cheney Federal Building, recounting how she got an alarmed phone call from her father on Jan. 6.

Ms. Cheney, Republican of Wyoming, recalled that she had been preparing to speak on the House floor in support of certifying Joseph R. Biden Jr.’s election as president. Mr. Cheney, the former vice president and his daughter’s closest political adviser, consulted with her on most days, but this time was calling as a worried parent.

He had seen President Donald J. Trump on television at a rally that morning vow to get rid of “the Liz Cheneys of the world.” Her floor speech could inflame tensions, he told her, and he feared for her safety. Was she sure she wanted to go ahead?

“Absolutely,” she told her father. “Nothing could be more important.”

Minutes later, Mr. Trump’s supporters breached the entrance, House members evacuated and the political future of Ms. Cheney, who never delivered her speech, was suddenly scrambled. Her promising rise in the House, which friends say the former vice president had been enthusiastically invested in and hoped might culminate in the speaker’s office, had been replaced with a very different mission.

“This is about being able to tell your kids that you stood up and did the right thing,” she said.

Ms. Cheney entered Congress in 2017, and her lineage always ensured her a conspicuous profile, although not in the way it has since blown up. Her campaign to defeat the “ongoing threat” and “fundamental toxicity of a president who lost” has landed one of the most conservative House members in the most un-Cheney-like position of resistance leader and Republican outcast. Ms. Cheney has vowed to be a counterforce, no matter how lonely that pursuit might be or where it might lead, including a possible primary challenge to Mr. Trump if he runs for president in 2024, a prospect she has not ruled out.

Beyond the daunting politics, Ms. Cheney’s predicament is also a father-daughter story, rife with dynastic echoes and ironies. An unapologetic Prince of Darkness figure throughout his career, Mr. Cheney was always attuned to doomsday scenarios and existential threats he saw posed by America’s enemies, whether from Russia during the Cold War, Saddam Hussein after the Sept. 11 attacks, or the general menace of tyrants and terrorists.

Ms. Cheney has come to view the current circumstances with Mr. Trump in the same apocalyptic terms. The difference is that today’s threat resides inside the party in which her family has been royalty for nearly half a century.

“He is just deeply troubled for the country about what we watched President Trump do,” Ms. Cheney said of her father. “He’s a student of history. He’s a student of the presidency. He knows the gravity of those jobs, and as he’s watched these events unfold, certainly he’s been appalled.”

On the day last month that Ms. Cheney’s House colleagues ousted her as the third-ranking Republican over her condemnations of Mr. Trump, she invited an old family friend, the photographer David Hume Kennerly, to record her movements for posterity. After work, they repaired to her parents’ home in McLean, Va., to commiserate over wine and a steak dinner.

“There was maybe a little bit of post-mortem, but it didn’t feel like a wake,” said Mr. Kennerly, the official photographer for President Gerald R. Ford while Mr. Cheney was White House chief of staff. “Mostly, I got a real sense at that dinner of two parents who were extremely proud of their kid and wanted to be there for her at the end of a bad day.”

Mr. Cheney declined to be interviewed for this article, but provided a statement: “As a father, I am enormously proud of my daughter. As an American, I am deeply grateful to her for defending our Constitution and the rule of law.”

The Cheneys are a private and insular brood, though not without tensions that have gone public. Ms. Cheney’s opposition to same-sex marriage during a brief Senate campaign in 2013 enraged her sister, Mary Cheney, and Mary’s longtime partner, Heather Poe. It was conspicuous, then, when Mary conveyed full support for her sister after Jan. 6.

“As many people know, Liz and I have definitely had our differences over the years,” she wrote in a Facebook post on Jan. 7. “But I am very proud of how she handled herself during the fight over the Electoral College…Good job Big Sister.’’

In an interview in Casper, Ms. Cheney, 54, spoke in urgent, clipped cadences in an unmarked conference room of the Dick Cheney Federal Building, one of many places that carry her family name in the nation’s least populous and most Trump-loving state. Her disposition conveyed both determination and worry, and also a sense of someone who had endured an embattled stretch.

Ms. Cheney had spent much of a recent congressional recess in Wyoming and yet was rarely seen in public. The appearances she did make — a visit to the Chamber of Commerce in Casper, a hospital opening (with her father) in Star Valley — were barely publicized beforehand, in large part for security concerns. She has received a stream of death threats, common menaces among high-profile critics of Mr. Trump, and is now surrounded by a newly deployed detail of plainclothes, ear-pieced agents.

Her campaign spent $58,000 on security from January to March, including three former Secret Service officers, according to documents filed with the Federal Election Commission. Ms. Cheney was recently assigned protection from the Capitol Police, an unusual measure for a House member not in a leadership position. The fortress aura around Ms. Cheney is reminiscent of the “secure undisclosed location” of her father in the days after the Sept. 11 attacks.

Ms. Cheney’s temperament bears the imprint of both parents, especially her mother, Lynne Cheney, a conservative scholar and commentator who is far more extroverted than her husband. But Mr. Cheney has long been his eldest daughter’s closest professional alter ego, especially after he left office in 2009, and Ms. Cheney devoted marathon sessions to collaborating on his memoir, “In My Times.” Their work coincided with some of Mr. Cheney’s gravest heart conditions, including a period in 2010 when he was near death.

His health stabilized after doctors installed a blood-pumping device that kept him alive and allowed him to travel. This included trips between Virginia and Wyoming in which Mr. Cheney would drive while dictating stories to Ms. Cheney in the passenger seat, who would type his words into a laptop. He received his heart transplant in 2012.

Father and daughter promoted the memoir in joint appearances, with Ms. Cheney interviewing her father in venues around the country. “She was basically there with her dad to ease his re-entry back to health on the public stage,” said former Senator Alan K. Simpson, a Wyoming Republican and a longtime family friend.

By 2016, Ms. Cheney had been elected to Congress and quickly rose to become the third-ranking Republican, a post her father also held. As powerful as Mr. Cheney was as vice president, he had always considered himself a product of the House, where he had served as Wyoming’s at-large congressman from 1979 to 1989.

Neither father nor daughter is a natural politician in any traditional sense. Mr. Cheney was a plotter and bureaucratic brawler, ambitious but in a quiet, secretive and, to many eyes, devious way. Ms. Cheney was largely focused on strategic planning and hawkish policymaking.

After graduating from Colorado College (“The Evolution of Presidential War Powers” was her senior thesis), Ms. Cheney worked at the State Department and the United States Agency for International Development while her father was defense secretary. She attended the University of Chicago Law School and practiced at the firm White & Case before returning to the State Department while her father was vice president. She was not sheepish or dispassionate like her father — she was a cheerleader at McLean High School — but held off running for office until well into her 40s.

Once in the House, Ms. Cheney was seen as a possible speaker — a hybrid of establishment background, hard-line conservatism and partisan instincts. While she had reservations about Mr. Trump, she was selective with her critiques and voted with him 93 percent of time and against his first impeachment.

As for Mr. Cheney, his distress over the Trump administration was initially focused on foreign policy, though he eventually came to view the 45th president’s performance overall as abysmal.

“I had a couple of conversations with the vice president last summer where he was really deeply troubled,” said Eric S. Edelman, a former American ambassador to Turkey, a Pentagon official in the George W. Bush administration and family friend.

As a transplant recipient whose compromised immune system placed him at severe risk of Covid-19, Mr. Cheney found that his contempt for the Trump White House only grew during the pandemic. He had also known and admired Dr. Anthony S. Fauci for many years.

At the same time, Ms. Cheney publicly supported Dr. Fauci and seemed to be trolling the White House last June when she tweeted “Dick Cheney says WEAR A MASK” over a photograph of her father — looking every bit the stoic Westerner — sporting a face covering and cowboy hat (hashtag “#realmenwearmasks”).

She has received notable support in her otherwise lonely efforts from a number of top-level figures of the Republican establishment, including many of her father’s old White House colleagues. Former President George W. Bush — through a spokesman — made a point of thanking Mr. Cheney “for his daughter’s service” in a call to his former vice president on his 80th birthday in January.

Ms. Cheney did wind up voting for Mr. Trump in November, but came to regret it immediately. In her view, Mr. Trump’s conduct after the election went irreversibly beyond the pale. “For Liz, it was like, I just can’t do this anymore,” said former Representative Barbara Comstock, Republican of Virginia.

Ms. Cheney returned last week to Washington, where she had minimal dealings with her former leadership cohorts and was less inhibited in sharing her dim view of certain Republican colleagues. On Tuesday, she slammed Representative Paul Gosar of Arizona for repeating “disgusting and despicable lies” about the actions of the Capitol Police on Jan. 6.

“We’ve got people we’ve entrusted with the perpetuation of the Republic who don’t know what the rule of law is,” she said. “We probably need to do Constitution boot camps for newly sworn-in members of Congress. Clearly.”

She said her main pursuit now involved teaching basic civics to voters who had been misinformed by Mr. Trump and other Republicans who should know better. “I’m not naïve about the education that has to go on here,” Ms. Cheney said. “This is dangerous. It’s not complicated. I think Trump has a plan.”

Ms. Cheney’s own plan has been the object of considerable speculation. Although she was re-elected in 2020 by 44 percentage points, she faces a potentially treacherous path in 2022. Several Wyoming Republicans have already announced plans to mount primary challenges against Ms. Cheney, and her race is certain to be among the most closely followed in the country next year. It will also provide a visible platform for her campaign to ensure Mr. Trump “never again gets near the Oval Office” — an enterprise that could plausibly include a long-shot primary bid against him in 2024.

Friends say that at a certain point, events — namely Jan. 6 — came to transcend any parochial political concerns for Ms. Cheney. “Maybe I’m being Pollyanna a little bit here, but I do think Liz is playing the long game,” said Matt Micheli, a Cheyenne lawyer and former chairman of the Wyoming Republican Party. Ms. Cheney has confirmed as much.

“This is something that determines the nature of this Republic going forward,” she said. “So I really don’t know how long that takes.”

Categories
Politics

Home Republicans Have Had Sufficient of Liz Cheney’s Fact-Telling

WASHINGTON – The first time Donald J. Trump’s defense attorneys came for Rep. Liz Cheney for voting against him for impeachment, Republicans closed their ranks to save her leadership position, and Rep. Kevin McCarthy boasted that theirs “big tent” party doing this had enough space for the former president and a strong critic.

Obviously not anymore.

Just three months after knocking back a vote of no confidence by a unilateral lead, the Republican of House No. 3, Ms. Cheney, of Wyoming, faces a far greater challenge that is more likely to end in her fall from the leadership. This time, Mr. McCarthy, the minority leader, encourages efforts to replace them.

Her transgression, say colleagues: Ms. Cheney’s continued public criticism of Mr. Trump, her condemnation of his lies about a stolen election, and her demand that the GOP tell the truth about how his supporters attacked democracy during the January 6 uprising in the Capitol to have .

The turnaround again reflects the passion with which Republicans have hugged Mr Trump and the voters who worship him, and how willing many members of the party are to uphold, or at least spread, falsehoods about the 2020 election that he has spread to tolerate.

What began as a struggle for the future of the party after the violent end of the Trump presidency has collapsed in a one-sided bunch by Team Trump with critics like Ms. Cheney, the scion of a famous Republican family and the lonely woman The house leadership of their party, ostracized or moving towards the exits.

The final test for Ms. Cheney could be as soon as next week, if a growing group of Republicans, with Mr. McCarthy’s blessing, plan another attempt to dethrone her. Many of her colleagues are now so confident that they will succeed that they openly discuss who will replace Ms. Cheney.

Tensions escalated Tuesday when Mr. McCarthy asked on Mr. Trump’s favorite newscast, Fox & Friends, whether Ms. Cheney could effectively carry out her role as the party’s top ambassador. (He previously told a Fox reporter, “I’ve had it with her” and “I’ve lost confidence,” according to a leaked recording of the exchange published by Axios.)

“I have heard from members who are concerned about their ability to carry out the work of conference chair and carry the message,” McCarthy said during the portion of the interview that was aired. “We all have to work as a unit if we can win the majority.”

Ms. Cheney, known for her steely temperament, has only dug herself harder with former allies. Minutes after Mr. McCarthy’s TV hit, she barbed her response through a spokesman, effectively suggesting that the minority leader and the Republicans who are cracking down on her were involved in Mr. Trump’s breakup.

“This is about whether the Republican Party will uphold lies about the 2020 elections and try to whitewash what happened on January 6,” said Jeremy Adler, the spokesman. “Liz won’t do that. That’s the problem. “

One of the few Republican voices willing to stand in Ms. Cheney’s defense was Senator Mitt Romney of Utah, who himself was attacked by his party for his unrepentant criticism of Mr. Trump – and even at the Republican Party conference in Utah was booed on Saturday.

“Every person with a conscience draws a line they will not go beyond: Liz Cheney refuses to lie,” wrote Romney on Twitter. “As one of my Republican Senate colleagues told me after my impeachment vote, ‘I don’t want to be part of a group that has punished someone for following their conscience.'”

Many House Republicans insist they have no problem with Ms. Cheney’s vote against Mr. Trump, which she called a decision of conscience. Nor, they say, are bothered by their neoconservative political positions, which – like that of their father, former Vice President Dick Cheney – lead to a falsehood that contradicts the “America First” position of the party that Mr. Trump cemented.

However, they fear that if they hope to portray Democrats as socialists of big governments that are so vicious, Ms. Cheney’s refusal to stop criticizing Mr. Trump or condemn the January 6 events could weaken the party’s message in the 2022 midterm elections are that they should be elected from the majority. It made Mr. Trump angry too.

Many, including Mr McCarthy, had hoped that as the elected leader, after surviving the February vote of no confidence, how the rest of the party would fare and just move on.

Instead, she has doubled in size and sometimes turned her fire on coworkers. The final straw for many came in Orlando last week, where Republicans gathered for their annual political retreat in hopes of sending a message of unity.

Ms. Cheney told Punchbowl News that in Wyoming – where she faces a major challenge – she would run a campaign to defend her impeachment vote “every day of the week.” She told reporters that any lawmakers who led the bid to invalidate President Biden’s election victory in Congress should be banned from running for president. And she broke off with Republican leaders when she said a proposed independent commission to investigate the Jan. 6 uprising should focus on a pro-Trump mob’s attack on the Capitol, rather than the violence by Antifa and Black Lives Matter as Investigate Mr. McCarthy and other Republicans have called.

A few days later, she attracted right-wing attacks for poking Mr Biden with her fist when he was speaking to a joint congressional session, and went to Twitter to defend herself for treating the President in a civil, respectful and dignified manner “had greeted.

“We are not sworn enemies,” she wrote. “We are Americans.”

On Monday, after Mr. Trump issued a statement calling the 2020 election “FRAGRANT” and “THE BIG LIE”, Ms. Cheney quickly tweeted her counter-argument, writing that anyone who made such claims was “our democratic system poisoned”.

Some Republicans have privately compared their performance to scab picking, and many of Mr. Trump’s allies saw this as an opening to try again to depose them.

“Liz tried (badly) to split our party,” Texas Republican Lance Gooden wrote on Twitter on Tuesday, mimicking Mr. Trump’s caustic Twitter style. “Trump is still the LEADER of the GOP, Liz! I look forward to it being removed soon! “

Ms. Cheney’s troubles show a rapid shift for the Republican Party in the few months since Mr. Trump left Washington. Early on, she was part of a small but influential group of Republicans that included Senator Mitch McConnell of Kentucky, the minority leader, and denounced Mr. Trump’s role in fueling the rebellion with false claims of a stolen election. But many of those lawmakers have since gone quiet, leaving Ms. Cheney, who was once enthusiastically talked about as future speaker or president, in isolation.

Ms. Cheney declined to speak through a spokesman and some of her allies in the House of Representatives failed to speak on the record in their defense, underscoring the tense nature of the vote and the pessimism some of them feel about their chances, another Challenge to survive. A spokeswoman for Illinois Representative Adam Kinzinger, another Republican who voted for the indictment against Mr. Trump and was a leading critic of the former president, said in a statement that the Congressman “clearly supports Liz Cheney as conference leader.”

Those who know her best say privately that Ms. Cheney’s predicament reflects both her principles and personality, including a stubborn trail that sometimes leads her to act against her self-interest. An ally who has been upset with her for the past few months described her actions as classic Liz Cheney: she will always do what she sees fit, the Republican said Tuesday, but she will just never stop believing that she is is wrong.

With Ms. Cheney’s support for Bleeding, Republicans have already begun going through the names of possible replacements for what has traditionally been seen as a stepping stone to the top positions in the party. Republicans are aware of the optics of replacing the only woman in the leadership with another man and are careful to choose a woman.

The lead candidate appears to be Representative Elise Stefanik of New York, a rising star in her fourth term who has spent a long time increasing the number of women in the Republican ranks and, more recently, a fierce defense attorney for Mr. Trump has become.

Ms. Stefanik, 36, has begun reaching out to Republican lawmakers to gauge her support, according to two people familiar with the private conversations. On Tuesday evening, one of her political advisors tweeted again speculation that she would “make an excellent conference chair. ”

Pennsylvania representative Guy Reschenthaler, a member of the Republican leadership who initially cast votes for Ms. Cheney, said he was counting potential votes for Ms. Stefanik and believed the job would be hers if she ran.

Republicans have also hovered Indiana representative Jackie Walorski as a possible alternative. As the Republican chief on the ethics committee, Ms. Walorski has successfully reconciled the task of condemning Representative Marjorie Taylor Greene’s earlier statements of conspiracy this year, arguing that she should not be expelled from their committees.